The darkness of depressions
The BioPsych project (2021-2023) focused on mental disorders such as depression, schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Here you can read the article on how the BioPsych team went looking for biological clues left by depression in 50-year old brain samples.
Right now, it's not just the winter darkness that descends upon us. So does the darkness of depression. With winter comes an increase in the number of depressions. As the seasons change and hopefully soon bring brighter days, researchers are working to help persons suffering from depression out of the darkness by increasing our understanding of what happens in our brains when depression strikes.
It actually looks more like one of the brown lunch bags you often see in American movies. The hand in the blue plastic glove reaches into the bag, but instead of a lunch sandwich, a small whitish block follows the gloved hand out of the bag. It is a small piece of a human brain. Betina Elving raises her hand in front of her face and looks at the small block before carefully placing it in a microtome, which is on the table in front of her. The microtome works a bit like a meat slicer. But instead of cutting meat or cold cuts into millimeter-thick slices for lunch, this device cuts out super-thin slices of human brain for scientific study.
Brains with untreated depression
Did you know that…
... the many thousands of brains in the Danish Brain Collection were collected without consent? Over time, this has led to questions about whether it is ethically correct to use the brains for research. Fortunately for research, it is now possible for anyone to apply for permission to do research projects with brain material from the collection.
Betina Elving is an Associate Professor in clinical medicine at Aarhus University. Over the past two years, she has looked at up to 50 different brains from the Danish Brain Collection. She is looking for biological clues. Clues that can help us understand what happens in the brain during depression. The brains in the collection have been collected from thousands of patients who died in Danish psychiatric hospitals in the period from 1945 to 1982. This means that many of the patients have not been treated with modern medicine. When Betina Elfving examines the brains, she can see how depression manifests itself in the biology of the brain.
Betina Elfving is driven by a scientific curiosity. Like a detective, she goes on a hunt to find the clues that the depression left behind in the patients' brains many years ago. At the same time, she is driven by a desire to make a difference for the many people who are affected by mental disorders, including depression, every year.
A complex and widespread disease
Did you know that…
… the author of the Harry Potter books, J. K. Rowling, has used her own experiences of severe depression to describe the impact of the Dementors on the characters in the books?
The Dementors are evil cloaked creatures that live by sucking out joy, good memories and energy of the people in the Harry Potter universe until the victims no longer have a soul.
The desire to make a difference is a welcome effort. Depression is often referred to as a widespread disease. This is not without reason: Almost one in five Danes is affected by depression during their lifetime, and the consequences extend far beyond the person suffering from depressed. According to the Danish Health Authority, direct costs in connection with depression sum up to almost DKK 9 billion per year. Depression also has large personal consequences for family and friends, who may experience how the person suffering from depression disappears into her or his own darkness. To have a bad conscience about letting down the closest relationships can intensify the depression and give rise to questions about whether it is actually one's own fault and whether one should just "get it together". But when suffering from depression, you can't just pull yourself together. When the darkness of depression first envelops you, you often feel a paramount sadness. Guilt, low self-esteem and negative thoughts often accompany the darkness. The symptoms of depression are not only psychological, because many also experience that both sleeping habits, eating patterns and sex drive change significantly.
There is no need to feel guilty. Depression is a complex disorder that can affect anyone, and the causes are an interaction between many different factors. For example, interactions with other diseases, environmental factors such as social status and experiences in your childhood have an impact, but biology also plays a role in the form of, among other things, heredity and various biological processes.
The biological clues
Biology is the primary focus of Betina Elfving's detective work when she is looking at the small pieces of old brains from patients suffering from depression. Her main focus is microscopic markers called microRNA. Because of their microscopic size, microRNAs are very stable. Therefore, these tiny clues are still found in the very old bricks from the Danish Brain Collection. "Often I have to cut off a bit to remove the outermost layer of brain tissue, which has been damaged during the long storage. But already after a few slices, I can examine the microRNA in the tissue," explains Betina Elving. She wants to find out which microRNAs are found in the depressed brains and how much of each microRNA there is. In other words, she is looking for a biomarker. Like a clue in a detective case, a good biomarker can show whether a certain biological process is taking place in the body. For example, there are already several examples of microRNA which can be used to detect some forms of cancer.
"In the future, biomarkers can hopefully be used for both diagnosis and treatment of psychiatric patients. Of course, the biomarkers cannot stand alone. But they can be an additional tool that can ensure faster and more targeted help for the person suffering from depression," Betina Elfving says.
Focus on helping patients
The patient perspective
The Danish author Peter Øvig Knudsen describes in the book ‘Jeg e hvad jeg husker’ ('I am what I remember') the ECT treatment he himself has successfully undergone, and which has changed his life completely. The book also contains a personal story from a patient named Pernille Frandsen, who, unlike Peter Øvig Knudsen, is not enthusiastic about ECT treatment.
It is not simple to find a good biomarker for depression. According to Professor of psychiatry at the Capital Region of Denmark Michael Eriksen Benros, the perfect biomarker must be as precise as possible. At the same time, the costs to measure the biomarker must be justified in relation to how important it is for treatment "Probably a biomarker found in the brain will be best. But we must be able to measure it in the patients without major interventions," he explains.
Poul Videbech, who is also a Professor at Region Hovedstadens Psykiatri (the psychiatric unit of the Capital Region of Denmark), says that the greatest potential for biomarkers lies in being able to prescribe the best possible treatment for the individual patient: "Right now we have several different forms of treatment and types of medicine. But not all treatments work equally well for everyone. Therefore we have to proceed by the method of trial and error. It would be really important for the treatment of depression if we could use a biomarker to predict whether a treatment will work or whether it has, for example, unacceptable side effects.”
Today, there are three general forms of treatment for patients with depression: Psychotherapy, medication, and ECT. Psychotherapy, where the patient learns to tackle psychological and personal challenges through a series of conversations with a professional, is most often the preferred treatment for patients with mild or moderate depression. In some cases, psychotherapy is combined with antidepressant medication. ECT, short for electroconvulsive therapy, is the official term for what was previously known as electroshock. Contrary to what many people think, ECT is still a used, and often very effective, form of treatment in psychiatry. It is used in particular for patients with severe depression with, for example, suicidal plans, where the doctors assess that there are no other options for recovery.
Men and women
Over many years, women have filled twice as much as men in the statistics of depression. However, according to project manager Michael Wichmann Pedersen from DepressionsForeningen (the Danish Depression Association), this does not necessarily mean that more women than men have depression. "This means that twice as many women are diagnosed with depression," he explains. He believes that there may be a large dark figure for men. Psychiatrist Michael Eriksen Benros fully supports this interpretation: "There may well be a large unreported figure of men, because they simply do not sufficiently consult a doctor - although of course there could potentially also be other contributing reasons."
Psychiatrist Poul Videbech does not necessarily think that there are a lot of men hiding in dark figures. "The causes of depression are incredibly complicated," he says. He points out that although women are certainly better at seeking a doctor, this alone cannot explain the big difference between men and women. Some of the difference can be explained, for example, by our own and others' expectations to ourselves, but the basic biology of the two sexes may also plays a role.
Differences in the brains
These differences between men and women make it obvious to think that the clues left behind by depression are different depending on whether you are a man or a woman. And this, exactly, spurs Betina Elving’s interest as a researcher. This is why she carefully, but seperately, looks at the biological clues in the brain samples of both men and women. "I actually see a difference between the two sexes: It is not the same microRNAs that are most abundant in male and female samples," she says. As already mentioned, her hope is that in the future one or more of these microRNAs can be used as biomarkers in men and women, respectively. "Previously, microRNAs have been studied across the sexes. But it is important to separate the two sexes in order to get a biomarker that is specific for either men or women," explains Betina Elfving. In this way, it will potentially be able to provide better treatment for the patients, because you cannot apply the same yardstick to everyone. The preliminary microRNA studies indicate that there are clear differences between the two sexes, and therefor women and men cannot be lumped together, believes Betina Elfving. Right now, treatment guidelines do not, for example, take the patient's gender into account, although there is probably a difference in how the antidepressants work for men and women.
While we are waiting for brighter days
Although Betina Elfving is currently continouing her work with various biomarkers in the laboratory, the persons suffering from depression do not immediately benefit. "It can take a long time before you know whether your research will be a breakthrough or not. Even if it is a breakthrough, we are talking about a time perspective of many years before the research benefits the patients," says psychiatrist Poul Videbech. He emphasizes that Betina Elving's approach to biomarkers in the old brains is original and that her research is important because it will give us new knowledge no matter what.
Even if it turns out that one of the biomarkers can "only" be used to make a diagnosis, it may still prove to be important for those suffering from depression. "If you can detect depression with an objective biomarker using, for example, a scan or a blood test, there is not much to discuss. Then you are sick," says psychiatrist Michael Eriksen Benros, thus suggesting that an objective test might help to reduce the taboo associated with depression.
This resonates with project manager Michael Wichmann Pedersen from the DepressionsForeningen: "We often see that there is less taboo about something physical. It's easier to talk about. Therefore, one can well assume that it could help decrease the taboo associated with depression if you have a precise biomarker to make the diagnosis.” Fortunately, the staff DepressionsForeningen believe that there is a development in society which makes it easier to talk about psychiatric disorders. Admittedly, depression still lags behind in relation to, for example, talking about seeing a psychologist or suffering from stress. But we are heading in the right direction. Towards a society where we can talk openly about depressions, while we are waiting for a more patient-specific and targeted treatment.
THE DARK NUMBERS OF DEPRESSION
Depression costs DKK 25 million in production losses per year in Denmark (sick days, early retirement and premature death)
Increased risk
Children of depressed parents have twice the risk of developing depression themselves
587,000 live with depression in Denmark
44% of all contacts with psychologists and psychiatrists in Denmark relate to depression
63 per day are affected by depression in Denmark. That's 23,000 new cases every year
Young when it strikes
You are usually 20-30 years old when you are first affected by depression
Recurrences
If you have already had one depression, you are at increased risk of having another depression at a later stage in life
7% of all contacts with general practitioners concern depression
Source: The website of ’Sundhedsstyrelsen’ (the Danish Health Autohirty) and their publication ’2022 Sygdomsbyrden i Danmark’ (2022 Disease burden in Denmark)
I didn't want to be labeled as weak
Lars, 56 years old, formerly depressed
"I think there are many people who hide depression behind a sick note with stress. Probably especially men. I myself have been one of them. I actually can't quite tell you why. Maybe it was because I didn't want to be labeled as weak. When you're stressed, it's because you've been busy. You’ve been efficient. Maybe too efficient. But depression has a more unpleasant ring to it.
As a child, I remember that my mother's friend Elna had 'bad nerves'. Back then, it covered everything possible. Also depression. Fortunately, we have become a more knowledgeable society now, and it is a great advantage that we all now have all kinds of knowledge at our fingertips. We no longer have to go to the library - we can just pick up the phone in our pocket. I think knowledge makes it easier to talk about mental disorders.
I was pleased to see that psychiatry was on the agenda for the negotiations on the last Danish annual budget. It is also good that there is now a 10-year plan for psychiatry. I therefore believe, and hope, that it will be better for psychiatric patients in the future.”
Maybe it would be easier if more people knew
Karen, 34 years old, suffering from depression for the third time
"At first it just comes quietly creeping up. There are a lot of thoughts in the back of my head, but suddenly there are so many that they start popping up and take over my whole head. And then all my energy disappears.
I find it difficult to talk about with others. Only my parents, siblings and my husband know I’m in the soup again. It takes courage to say 'I feel really bad at the moment', and I don't have that courage right now. After all, I'm afraid that others will say 'Awww... I feel bad for you!' and in that way I stigmatize their reaction. I also think they might find themselves asking what has done it. But I can't explain that when it's a million different things and everything suddenly becomes too much.
Maybe it would be easier if more people knew. On the one hand, I want others to just treat me as they normally would. On the other hand, I also sometimes need extra time or an extra helping hand. Right now I use all the energy I have to be there for my child. But she can feel that I'm not really there. The worst is when she prefers her father over me.”